You may have heard someone talk about converting an IRA account. What does that mean, exactly? And are there reasons why you should consider converting a traditional IRA into a Roth?
Roth IRAs may be attractive for several reasons. With traditional IRAs (and traditional qualified plans like 401(k)s), the money you contribute to the plan is not taxed, but you have to pay ordinary income taxes whenever you take money out of the account—which might be years in the future. The Roth reverses this; your contribution is made with after-tax dollars (the contribution doesn’t reduce your taxable income), but then there’s no tax whenever the money is distributed during retirement.
If you believe, as many financial professionals do, that tax rates are going to go up in the future, then paying taxes now—at a presumably lower rate—and eliminating future taxes on withdrawals provides a net gain.
Another interesting thing about Roths is that, unlike traditional IRAs, they don’t have any minimum distribution requirements once you turn age 72. So long as the money remains in the account, both Roths and traditional IRAs give you the benefits of tax deferral, which eliminates a significant drag on the growth of your money. If you can afford to keep your money in the Roth account and take retirement income from other sources, then the deferral can go on longer.
Finally, having money in a Roth account can give you a lot more control over your tax bracket in retirement. For instance, you might take out just enough from your traditional IRA distributions to fill the 15% bracket, and then take the rest of your living expenses out of your taxable accounts and Roth. This kind of planning might help higher-income retirees reduce taxes on their Social Security income and avoid higher Medicare premiums. If a married couple can keep traditional IRA distributions low enough that their the taxable retirement income is below $44,000, then they would pay taxes on just 50% of their Social Security income; otherwise, they pay taxes (at a potentially higher tax bracket) on 85% of those benefits. The higher Medicare premiums start at $182,000 of joint tax return income.
The Roth account will still be subject to estate taxes, and your heirs (not your spouse) will have to take the money out of the account over the ten years after the inheritance. But if they inherit a Roth account, they won’t have to pay taxes on the distributions they receive–a nice additional gift for your children or grandchildren.
Every situation is different, so you and your financial advisor should carefully asses your situation before you pull the conversion trigger. Fortunately, the law allows for partial Roth conversions—moving some of the money over, rather than all of it—so that each conversion can be managed to avoid putting you into a higher tax bracket.
Timing the Conversion
When you convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, you will owe taxes on any money that would have been taxed when withdrawn, including the tax-deductible contributions and the tax-deferred earnings accumulated over the years. The total amount converted is taxed as income in the year of conversion, which might push you into a higher tax bracket.
However, there are strategies to mitigate the tax burden. For instance, converting in a year when your income is unusually low can reduce the tax impact. Additionally, if the value of your retirement account has dropped (perhaps because of a tough market cycle), converting at that time means a lower tax bill compared to converting when the account is worth more.
No Limits on Conversions
There are no limits on the number and size of Roth conversions you can make from a traditional IRA. While the IRS restricts rollovers between traditional IRAs to one per year, this limit does not apply to conversions to Roth IRAs. You can convert all your tax-deferred savings at once, but doing so might not be advisable due to potential tax consequences.
A more prudent approach might be executing conversions over several years, particularly when your income is lower. This method can help you pay less tax on each dollar converted and avoid pushing your income into a higher tax bracket. There is sometimes a golden period for people who retire early but aren’t yet pulling money out of their Traditional IRAs, nor have they started Social Security. Those in this stage of life may have amassed a sizeable tax-deferred balance, but they live off non-IRA funds, so their taxable income can sometimes be relatively low.
The Five-Year Rule
While regular Roth IRA contributions can be withdrawn tax- and penalty-free at any time, converted funds must remain in the Roth IRA for at least five years to avoid a 10% early withdrawal penalty. This five-year period starts at the beginning of the calendar year in which the conversion is made. Each conversion has its own five-year period, so multiple conversions will each have separate timelines.
Is a Roth conversion right for you? At Milestone Money, we help clients analyze their unique situations to come up with personalized solutions that can help them achieve their important financial goals. To find out if paying taxes now in order to obtain tax-free income later is the right solution for your retirement, get in touch with us. And to learn more, visit our website to read our article, “Retirement Your Way: Looking at Options.”


