Anyone preparing for retirement understands the need to build up the “nest egg” as much as possible. In fact, your financial advisor probably spends a significant amount of time emphasizing the essentials for retirement security: put as much as you can into your tax-advantaged accounts (401(k)s, 403(b)s, IRAs, etc.) and your taxable investment accounts so you’ll have a solid financial foundation as you begin your retirement.
What sometimes gets less attention is developing a plan for spending those funds when it’s time to start using them to sustain your retirement lifestyle. In other words, though most people are very focused on a saving and investment strategy, many don’t consider the importance of a withdrawal strategy. But making the most tax-efficient use of your various retirement savings “buckets” is vital to extending and maintaining the spending power of your retirement savings.
Remember: the average American is expected to live between 20 and 22 years past their 65th birthday, according to the Social Security Administration. In fact, about a fourth of those age 65 today can expect to live past age 90, and about 10% will live past 95. In other words, many of us will live 30 years or more in retirement. And as time goes on, average life spans may be expected to increase. This means that we should be giving careful thought to the best ways to extend our retirement income streams as much as we can, while also paying the least possible in taxes, including the portion of Social Security income that is subject to taxation. Retirement income withdrawal strategies should consider taxable and non-taxable sources of income, along with the growth and volatility characteristics of assets in all accounts.
What Is Withdrawal Sequencing?
Retirement income withdrawal sequencing involves considering all your sources of retirement income, including tax-advantaged accounts like annuities, IRAs, 401(k)s, and 403(b)s; guaranteed income streams like Social Security and pension accounts; taxable sources like dividends, interest, and capital gains from taxable investments; and other sources such as rental income or other payouts from business interests. Based on your particular mix of sources, you can work with your financial advisor to decide how much to withdraw from taxable and tax-advantaged accounts to minimize your overall tax burden in retirement and extend the life of your nest egg.
For example, you may need to look at your traditional (pre-tax) IRAs and 401(k)s to evaluate your required minimum distributions (RMDs) and how they will affect your taxable income for a given year. RMD planning should take into consideration your other sources of income to help you anticipate the amount of taxable income you are expecting, with the goal of keeping you in the lowest marginal bracket possible.
Another element in withdrawal sequencing strategy involves Roth conversion timing. By strategically using lower-tax-bracket years to convert traditional IRAs and other pre-tax retirement accounts to after-tax Roth accounts, many retirees can reduce the impact of RMDs on their taxable income in retirement and also gain greater control over the timing of tax-free retirement income. When a traditional account is converted to a Roth account, taxes must be paid on the converted amount, which is why it may make sense to do the conversion in a year when the taxpayer is in a lower marginal bracket. And, because Roth accounts have no RMDs, the taxpayer can choose when (or if) to take a withdrawal from the account in retirement. Finally, Roth withdrawals are not taxed in retirement, giving the taxpayer sources of tax-free income.
Creating a Sustainable Retirement Income Strategy
Traditionally, the advice has been for retirees to first utilize taxable accounts (regular investment accounts), then tap tax-deferred sources (traditional retirement accounts like IRAs, 401(k)s, or 403(b)s funded with pre-tax dollars), and finally, to pull income from tax-free sources such as Roth retirement accounts, which are funded with after-tax dollars, and tax-free bonds or bond funds. This is a pretty easy concept to grasp, and it allows tax-deferred and tax-free sources to grow and compound without the drag of taxation for as long as possible. Of course, income generated from regular investment accounts is taxable, either as ordinary income (including non-qualified dividends and short-term capital gains), qualified dividends, or long-term capital gains (LTCG); the latter two may be taxed at a rate below the taxpayer’s marginal rate. Income from tax-deferred accounts (like traditional 401(k)s, 403(b)s, and IRAs) is also taxed as ordinary income when the funds are withdrawn from the account.
But the “conventional wisdom” sometimes overlooks a couple of important factors for retirement income: the effect of required minimum distributions (RMDs) and the impact on the taxation of Social Security income.
Currently, the first $32,000 of Social Security income for a married couple filing jointly is not taxed. From $32,001–44,000, 50% of it is taxable. Above $44,000, 85% of Social Security income is taxable. This is why a smart withdrawal strategy takes into consideration the amount and character of taxable income being used each year.
Remember: balances in tax-deferred accounts like traditional IRAs can’t be left there indefinitely; by age 72, most taxpayers are required to start taking RMDs from these accounts. As RMDs add to the taxpayer’s ordinary income, “bracket creep” can sometimes become a problem.
Finally, remember that the main goal for most retirees is to avoid outliving their money. For others, an auxiliary goal might be to leave as much of the estate as possible for their heirs.
With all that in mind, some retirees could benefit from a different method. Instead of allowing tax-deferred accounts to continue accumulating until taxable sources are exhausted, it may make sense to draw some income from these accounts earlier in retirement, paying tax on them as ordinary income. This can allow the taxpayer to spread out the tax burden on the deferred amounts over a longer span and also potentially reduce the size of the RMDs required in later years. Depending on how much income other than Social Security is available to the taxpayer, this may also keep more of the taxpayer’s Social Security income from being subject to tax. It also continues the benefit of delaying the use of Roth accounts, creating the possibility for a longer stream of tax-free income in the later years of retirement.
By “biting the bullet” a little earlier in retirement and taking measured distributions from tax-deferred sources, many retirees may be able to reduce the amount of taxes paid over their retired lifetimes and potentially conserve more tax-free or tax-advantaged assets for the benefit of their heirs.
At Milestone Money, we know that building up your retirement savings as much as possible is important. But we also know that having a tax-smart strategy for extending the life of your savings can be just as vital. If you have questions about your retirement strategy, we can help you find the answers you need.


